
Comparing the Top-Five Video Transfer Companies
An honest comparison of the top-five services for digitizing VHS and other family video tapes.
As the premium provider in the industry, our team at EverPresent is well suited to evaluate the industry. We’re a bit more expensive, and in this article you’ll get a sense of why. Our premium service may be worth it for you, and if not, we hope this article helps you find the right fit for your budget. Our mission here is to preserve history before it’s too late, and what matters most is that you digitize your tapes sooner rather than later, regardless of which video digitizing service you choose.
Before we dive in, two quick notes:
- In this article we compare five companies: EverPresent, LegacyBox, iMemories, ScanCafe and CVS/Walmart (served by Capture via shipping to their Atlanta facility). The short version is that these are the only companies with the scale to serve the national need for video tape transfer. If you’d like to understand more about this, we have also written general evaluations of each company.
- There are over 2,000 smaller digitizing companies across the country. They tend to have thinner websites, and can be difficult to evaluate. Some are excellent, though, and we need to evaluate them internally sometimes to help clients who need rush service we can’t provide. We have written a guide to how to evaluate smaller video transfer companies that you may find helpful.
Below is the outline for our evaluation. Feel free to click the links below to skip ahead to the section that most interests you.
Technology & Options
HD Upscaling
Labeling
Formats
Output
Restorative Services
Shipping & Dropoff Experience
Shopping & Service Experience
Inventory & Quotes
Order Approval & Payments
Personalized Ordering Experience
Digital Delivery Options
Technology & Options
HD Upscaling
The vast majority of video tapes were recorded in what we now think of as “standard definition” or SD. The most common format, the VHS tape, was recorded at 480p. People have been working on the ability to upscale to create sharper viewing for a long time, but historically it created too many artifacts and inaccuracies. That has changed recently, with accurate upscaling to HD now available, and it makes a noticeable difference especially when viewing digitized video footage on big screen TVs. As of this writing:
- HD upscaling is offered by
- EverPresent
- iMemories
- HD upscaling is not offered by
- LegacyBox
- ScanCafe
- CVS/Walmart
EverPresent charges $4/tape for this service, whereas iMemories and Capture list at $10 (although it’s often discounted). Based on our review, all three services do equivalent upscaling and we’d be comfortable with any of them.
Labeling
The written label on a video tape is gold. With any luck it’ll tell you much of the who/what/when/where – and whatever is there is better than a label like “Video Tape #1”. EverPresent is the clear winner here, offering full done-for-you transcription of written tape labels into filenames on USBs and Cloud, along with DVD menus. ScanCafe is willing to do it with a custom request but with a strict and often unhelpful 20-character limitation. The other services require you to login to their app to do it, which is laborious and not particularly helpful if you plan to consume the videos via USB or DVD.
Formats Digitized
Over 90% of the video tapes in existence are the VHS formats (VHS, VHS-C, SVHS), 8mm formats (Hi8, Video8, Digital8) and MiniDV. All companies service these formats well, along with handling less common Betamax and MicroMV tapes. So this factor may not matter to many consumers. There are many other formats and what’s noteworthy is two aspects:
1. If you have these formats, most companies will send them back un-digitized and you’ll have to start over.
2. These other formats were common with institutions and broadcasters, so when a company services them, you know they are dealing with the most discerning clients.
EverPresent offers digitizing of all of the primary additional formats, including ¾ inch Umatic, all of the Betacam formats, all of the DVC formats, along with HDCam, PAL and a few others. Again, EverPresent is the clear winner here, but for many clients this factor will not matter.
Output Format Options
The .mp4 video file in the h264 codec has become the standard for streaming due to its relatively efficient ~1.5GB/hour file size. All companies offer this, and it’s the most practical for streaming and laptop hard drive utilization. There are industrial strength alternatives preferred by archivists and film producers, including the ProRes formats and JPEG2000. EverPresent is the only top-five company to offer these alternatives, which are mainly used by its institutional clients, but are available to all clients regardless of the size of their order.
Restorative Services
The average video tape was recorded many decades ago at this point. There are five primary things that can go wrong with the video tape that can prevent a successful digitizing:
- Mechanical breakage in the tape casing. The fix is to either repair the flap or replace the entire case.
- Tears in the magnetic tape itself. The fix is to splice the tape back together.
- Mold due to storage in damp conditions. The fix is to literally clean the magnetic tape and the casing in a safe environment before digitizing.
- Sticky shed syndrome, which is a fraying of the magnetic tape as it ages. The solution is generally a multi-hour incubation to properly hydrate the footage, with transfer necessary within 24-hours of the process to maximize the restorative effect.
- Synchronization issues due to magnetism effects, leading to dropped frames and/or sound and video misaligning. This is repaired using special time base correction devices.
EverPresent is the only top-five company to advertise services to address all five of these common issues on its website. The Internet is rife with complaints about the other services rejecting difficult tapes.
Technology & Options – Overall Evaluation
Overall, EverPresent provides the most comprehensive and sophisticated services – and the way it manifests is the highest probability that all of your tapes will be digitized to maximum quality possible. Ultimately, if you have the most common formats, are reasonably sure the video tapes are in good working condition, do not require HD upscaling, and you don’t mind doing the label transcription yourself, any of the companies should do an adequate job.
Shipping & Dropoff Experience
Among the top-five companies, there are two offering versions of a local experience:
1. EverPresent offers home pickups and drop-off via retail location, with full barcoding and tracking, throughout the east coast. All transit is handled by its own private logistics network, drivers and vehicles to its nearest digitizing lab.
2. CVS & Walmart offer drop-off at its photo counters, where staff make things convenient for clients by taking care of the packaging of the materials. Items are then sent via mail to the central Atlanta processing facility run by Capture. So while this model fundamentally relies on the postal services, it is quite convenient for clients.
When it comes to traditional shipping, all of these companies offer mail-in service for all 50 states, but with different approaches:
- Approach #1: Ship Kit
- This is the approach used by iMemories and ScanCafe
- You initially pay a modest fee for the box to be sent to your house (usually $20-30), after which you fill it and send it off.
- Approach #2: Fully Prepaid Box
- This is the approach used by LegacyBox
- You pay for your whole order online (i.e. a 10-tape box), and then an appropriately sized box is sent your way.
- Approach #3: Prepaid Shipping Labels
- This is the approach used by EverPresent
- The con here is that you have to use your own boxes. The pro is that they arrive immediately, so you don’t have to wait, and you can use them on whatever box or boxes make the most sense. You also literally pay nothing upfront for these shipping labels as part of EverPresent’s general free estimate approach.
Shopping & Service Experience
This is a relatively straightforward section and can be reviewed in the table below. In our other reviews, of photo scanning for example, this area matters tremendously. But for a typical order of under 20 video tapes, all of the shopping experiences work adequately and have their pros and cons. But we do need to expound on one aspect of the service experience, which is digital delivery options. Everybody offers USB thumb drives and DVDs and some version of a cloud experience. On that front, there are two approaches:
- Service via third-party (like Google Drive)
- This approach is used by ScanCafe and CVS/Walmart
- Private app experience
- This approach is used by EverPresent, LegacyBox and iMemories
If you are simply getting a few tapes digitized and want to download them for personal use, all of the services are equivalent. We would just point out that whereas most services include a digital download in base pricing, LegacyBox does not and that can catch people off guard in the ordering process. Make sure to click that option (it’s usually a buck or three per tape).
In terms of the private apps, EverPresent and iMemories stand out:
- iMemories has the most robust SmartTV streaming options right now, covering all major TV manufacturers. If your aim is to keep your videos with your digitizing company’s cloud platform and you like watching on the big screen, iMemories has done a great job here and you’ll be happy with this.
- EverPresent offers casting to televisions directly from its smartphone app along with SmartTV apps coming soon for all major platforms. What sets EverPresent apart is its Key Moments technology. Most families have dozens of hours of video footage, and it can be complicated to find the best parts. EverPresent’s technology evaluates your video, identifies around 10 “key moments” for each video that you can skip to and share individually, along with summaries, transcripts – and it even tells you which family members “star” in each video.
Shopping & Service Experience – Overall Evaluation
If you just have a few video tapes, the experience will be adequate with all of the companies. But if you have a larger archive of video tapes, the cloud platforms at EverPresent and iMemories are real differentiators. And if it’s important to you to have a discussion with an expert to review the options before making budget decisions on a large order, EverPresent also stands out.
Conclusion
EverPresent is the clear winner, as it should be as the premium provider who charges a bit more than the competition. EverPresent wins on:
- Technical sophistication
- Restorative capabilities
- Organized archives
- Local service options
- Cloud experience
The other options are lower cost than EverPresent, although saving a few bucks per tape across a typical collection of 10-20 tapes usually saves under $100, so the EverPresent premium is likely worthwhile. But if budget is a concern, LegacyBox is great for gifting this project to your elders, and iMemories brings the most to the table of the discounters when it comes to HD upscaling and app quality. CVS/Walmart are ultimately just as expensive as EverPresent, and ScanCafe doesn’t stand out in this area (they are much more known for their image scanning services).
*Information regarding competitors is based on public research and market knowledge available at the time of publication. Product features, and service offerings are subject to change. EverPresent does not guarantee the absolute accuracy of competitor data. Please verify all information directly with the respective service provider.





