How to Find the Best Companies For Audio Transfers

Audio tapes, reel-to-reel and vinyl records represent some of the most challenging digitizing projects

Audio digitizing represents, by far, the most challenging digitizing field.  For one, it’s just audio – there’s nothing to look at – so if the audio is not great, the entire experience of reliving the memories is very underwhelming.  The materials themselves are also exceedingly fragile.  Vinyls break, bend and scratch easily.  Audio reels are exceedingly vulnerable to degradation and sticky shed syndrome.  And audio tapes were often recorded on very amateur devices on a very flimsy media type, and they have not aged well.  Audio digitizing also represents under 5% of the digitizing business, so it’s not a huge area of emphasis or focus for most digitizing companies.  So the problem you run into is that it’s the most difficult format, but the one where providers have the least incentive to invest.  There’s no service where it matters more to pick the right provider, and we’ve provided you some insider questions to ask anyone you’re considering hiring so you make the right choice.  The good news – great providers are out there.  Audio is a passion field and the elite practitioners go the extra mile.

Why this matters? If the answer is only audio cassettes, we recommend looking elsewhere.  It’s easy to set up a low-end audio tape transfer business with <$100 equipment with negligible expertise.  

Answers you want to hear: Anybody engaged in reel-to-reel audio transfer and DAT tapes is more likely to have a proper setup for audio transfer.

Why this matters: Amazon is full of very cheap machines (think those old dictation machines) that do a terrible job.

Answers you want to hear: Sony is reliable, and if you hear brands like TEAC, Nakamichi and Ampex, you’re talking to a serious audio digitizing lab.

Why this matters? You want ease of use and archival quality.

Answers you want to hear: Generally, audio digitizing platforms go directly to a standard .wav file, and that’s fine for basic digitizing and we use it all the time.  For ease of use on portable players, you also want to hear that a company offers .mp3 files, along with track splitting and labeling for ease of navigation.  You’re really in business if a company also mentions upgraded .wav files, like 24-bit, or .FLAC files.  If you are hearing that language, it means the shop engages in archive-level audio transfers for sophisticated clients.

Why this matters: Audio formats are often in mediocre shape, and you don’t want your company rejecting the challenging ones.

Answers you want to hear: 

  • For vinyl record digitizing, you primarily want to hear that the company cleans the vinyls before digitizing.  It’s crazy not to, but most companies don’t.
  • For audio reels, you want to hear that the company offers incubation to address sticky shed syndrome.  This process rehabilitates fraying magnetic tape on the audio reel and lubricates it before digitizing.  It’s the difference between the digitizing physically damaging the reel vs. it coming out dramatically better.
  • For audio tapes, you want to hear that the company can splice broken tape and recase damaged cassette cartridges.

Why this matters: Sound restoration technology has advanced a lot and is often included, so you don’t want to miss out.

Answer you want to hear: You should expect that basic equalizing, de-noising and gain staging are included.  Simply put this is the act of making quieter recordings louder, and generally outputting your audio memories at a consistent, discernable volume.  It’s cheap and easy to do and you should always receive this service.  A more advanced company will be offering relevant upgrades.  For example:

  • Ask if your vinyl transfer company offers de-crackle restoration for damaged vinyls
  • Ask if your audio cassette transfer company offers de-hiss restoration
  • Ask if your reel-to-reel transfer company can handle time stretching or multi-track situations

The purpose of this article is to help you evaluate any audio transfer company.  At EverPresent we are huge proponents of local digitizing companies, and this article will help you pick the good ones, especially outside of the 14 states where we provide local service.

For those of you open to the mail, below we have provided a detailed comparison of the five largest digitizing  companies in America.

Comparing The Five Largest Digitizing Services

An honest comparison to help you choose the best company for your project.

Digitizing Audio

Our team believes audio transfer is the most challenging format due to the rapid aging of the source media and inconsistent original microphone quality.  Even our standard level of service involves both human and AI-enabled optimizations to ensure a high-integrity listening experience.

EverPresent

LegacyBox

iMemories

ScanCafe

CVS, Walmart

✅
Audio cassette tapes,
vinyl records,
reel-to-reel audio, microcassettes,
mini cassettes, DAT tapes, CDs

✅
Audio cassette tapes,
Reel-to-reel audio,
microcassettes,
mini cassettes

❌
Not Available

❌
Cassette tapes;
Reel-to-reel tapes

❌
Not Available

✅
Basic equalizing and optimization

❌
Not available

❌
Not available

✅
Remove dead space

❌
Not available

✅
Advanced equalizing, de-hiss,
decrackle and more

❌
Not available

❌
Not available

❌
Not available

❌
Not available

✅
Custom track splitting;
track labeling

❌
Not available

❌
Not available

❌
Not available

❌
Not available

✅
16-bit or 24-bit .wav
or .mp3 streaming files + .wav

❌
.mp3

❌
Not available

✅
.wav

❌
Not available

Shipping & Drop-off Experience

All transport between our stores, your homes and our high-tech labs is handled by our private in-house logistics network that’s 100% devoted to safely transporting your precious photos and videos.

EverPresent

LegacyBox

iMemories

ScanCafe

CVS, Walmart

✅
Yes. Northeast, Delaware, Maryland, Virginia, DC, Florida

❌
Not available

❌
Not available

❌
Not available

❌
Not available

✅
Yes. Over 130 local stores.

❌
Not available

❌
Not available

❌
Not available

✅
Local stores receive
projects that are then shipped to Atlanta

✅
Included

✅
Included

❌
Surcharge

❌
Surcharge

✅
Included

✅
Free labels to be used on
any sized box

❌
Fully prepaid box; size limits

❌
Prepaid ship kit; size limits

✅
Prepaid ship kit or mail yourself

✅
Boxed and shipped for you at retail counter

Shopping & Service Experience

We are the only major national company that makes it 100% free to get us your project, counts everything for you, build an inventory, and provides a free estimate and personal consultation before you pay a dime.

EverPresent

LegacyBox

iMemories

ScanCafe

CVS, Walmart

✅
Formats identified and counted for you

❌
You do the work

❌
You do the work

❌
You do the work

❌
You do the work

✅
Free quote provided, pay after approval

❌
Fully pre-pay before sending in your project

❌
Pre-pay for ship kit

✅
Pre-pay for ship kit
OR 75% deposit based on
DIY counts

❌
Fully pre-pay before sending in your project

✅
Choice of phone consultation or online self-service

❌
Online shopping cart

❌
Online shopping cart

✅
Online shopping cart with option to call first

❌
Online shopping cart

✅
Download and private cloud app free for 60 days

❌
Downloads not included in listed pricing

✅
Download and private cloud app free for 30 days

❌
Download from a .zip file via email or sign up for third-party hosting

❌
Available for 60 days via Google download

*Information regarding competitors is based on public research and market knowledge available at the time of publication. Product features, and service offerings are subject to change. EverPresent does not guarantee the absolute accuracy of competitor data. Please verify all information directly with the respective service provider.

Format Guides
EverPresent audio formats guide
Audio cassettes
Vinyl records
Reel-to-reel tapes
DAT tapes
8 Track vs. Cassette Tapes

Helpful Articles
Understanding the difference between analog and digital audio
How long before cassette tapes go bad
What is sticky shed syndrome and how do you treat it?
How to properly store vintage audio formats
Archival audio formats – .wav vs .flac
How to clean vinyl records before digitizing
How to tell the difference between audio and film reels

*Information regarding competitors is based on public research and market knowledge available at the time of publication. Product features, and service offerings are subject to change. EverPresent does not guarantee the absolute accuracy of competitor data. Please verify all information directly with the respective service provider.

Fill out this form or give us a call