How To Find the Best Film Transfer Company

Detailed questions to ask when evaluating services for converting 8mm, Super8 or 16mm film to digital, and our review of the America’s top-five film transfer companies.

Our team at EverPresent is especially proud of our film transfer services.  Between our two brands, EverPresent and Just8mm, we digitize more home movie films than anyone in America.  That said, we cannot handle it all, and we are not local everywhere.  There are hundreds of small shops providing film transfers across the country, and we need all of them to preserve these cherished memories.  That said, this project only gets done once, and it has to be done right, and in our experience the variance in quality of film transfers is wider than on any other service.  That’s why we’re providing this guide to help you evaluate and identify the right company for your film transfer project.

Why does this matter?  It must be a sprocketless frame-by-frame scanner.  If you hear “custom-built” or “home-made” or “proprietary” it means the company is doing some version of projecting film and recording the projection with a video camera, often using old sprockets to project the film which create jitter and instability.  That technology is cheap, and antiquated.  Film scanning technology is advancing every year, and the best companies will be able to tell you the exact manufacturer.

Answers you want to hear: MWA Nova, Lasergraphics, BlackMagic / Cintel, DFT / Prasad or Filmfabriek.  These are all $75K to $250K digitizing rigs that do what you need – 2K, high-definition, frame-by-frame scans.  In the film transfer industry, this is like BMW, Lexus, Mercedes, etc. – except where the lesser brands are more like riding a bike.  These machines are fast and good, so they don’t cost much more than lesser services.  This is the first question you should ask, and all of these machines will get the job done for any family 8mm or 16mm film to digital project.

Why does this matter?  In our experience, over 10% of reels need a fix of some kind to be safely and successfully digitized.

Answers you want to hear:  You want to hear that splicing of damaged film is included in the transfer price, and that cleaning of mold is available.  This is very important, as many companies simply return moldy film un-digitized, and mold is very common on film reels.  If you are a highly discerning client looking for the best service, you should specifically ask if wet-gate transfers are offered.  Wet-gate applies a solution to film before it’s digitized, which lubricates the film and fills in the small cracks and scratches, creating a cleaner, repaired film transfer.

Why does this matter?  AI upscaling immediately tells you the company is not using a top-end transfer machine.

Answers you want to hear: Native.  This means the transfer machine is using frame-by-frame technology with a modern, best-in-class optical element.  AI upscaling is unavoidable for video tapes that simply don’t have the pixels in the original recording.  But it’s unnecessary for film transfers.  This does not mean that AI doesn’t have a place in film transfers, but it should be reserved for stabilization, grain reduction and other de-aging dynamics.  

Why does this matter? For efficiency on scarce equipment, most companies combine various 50-foot reels onto a single master reel and then digitize it at once.  This makes sense, but you do not want to simply be returned one file for that entire master reel.

Answer you want to hear: A single .mp4 file for each reel, with any written label transcribed into the filename.  In our experience, over 80% of films have a written label, but most transfer companies don’t preserve them.

Why does this matter?  While you likely do not need this service, if a service offers this, it tells you they work regularly with discerning archivists, museums, filmmakers, etc.

Answer you want to hear: Yes – and the buzzwords are: ProRes or JPEG2000.

Why does this matter?  The vast majority of film transfer companies do not capture sound. Roughly 90% of film is silent, but the 10% that has sound is important to preserve, and most companies skip it.

Answer you want to hear: Yes – and specifically, you want to hear that companies can capture both magnetic audio strips and optical strips. If you have regular 8mm film to transfer, you likely don’t have to worry about this. But magnetic sound is fairly common in Super8 conversions, and 16mm film can have magnetic or optical sound tracks. This is a must to confirm before you pick a film transfer company.

Comparing The Five Largest Film to Digital Transfer Companies

An honest comparison to help you choose the best company to digitize your 8mm film and other film to digital projects.

Digitizing Film Reels

We recently upgraded our film transfer machine to the BMW/Mercedes of the industry – the MWA Nova. It’s a $100K machine that dramtically performs the equpment used by out competitors. We know – we used to use the methodology everyone uses until we upgraded.

EverPresent

LegacyBox

iMemories

ScanCafe

CVS, Walmart

✅
True native 2K
frame-by-frame capture

❌
Not available

❌
Software
upscale only

❌
Not available

❌
Not available

✅
Done for You;
Transcribed from your film reel boxes
or included label instructions

❌
DIY
In App Only

❌
DIY
In App Only

✅
Per item labeling can be reqeusted,
up to 20 characters

❌
Folder labels only

✅
8mm sound strips captured AND
16mm optical sound;
16mm magnetic sound

❌
Sound not captured

✅
8mm sound strips only

✅
8mm sound strips only

✅
8mm sound strips only

✅
AI upgrades for stabilization, exposure, color, degraining and sharpness

❌
Not available

✅
AI enhancement available

❌
Not available

❌
Not available

✅
Available: Repair, mold cleaning, incubation, wetgate mitigation of scratches and blemishes

❌
Not available

❌
None Advertised

❌
None Advertised

❌
None Advertised

Shopping & Service Experience

We are the only major national company that makes it 100% free to get us your project, counts everything for you, build an inventory, and provides a free estimate and personal consultation before you pay a dime.

EverPresent

LegacyBox

iMemories

ScanCafe

CVS, Walmart

✅
Formats identified and counted for you

❌
You do the work

❌
You do the work

❌
You do the work

❌
You do the work

✅
Free quote provided, pay after approval

❌
Fully pre-pay before sending in your project

❌
Pre-pay for ship kit

✅
Pre-pay for ship kit
OR 75% deposit based on
DIY counts

❌
Fully pre-pay before sending in your project

✅
Choice of phone consultation or online self-service

❌
Online shopping cart

❌
Online shopping cart

✅
Online shopping cart with option to call first

❌
Online shopping cart

✅
Download and private cloud app free for 60 days

❌
Downloads not included in listed pricing

✅
Download and private cloud app free for 30 days

❌
Download from a .zip file via email or sign up for third-party hosting

❌
Available for 60 days via Google download

*Information regarding competitors is based on public research and market knowledge available at the time of publication. Product features, and service offerings are subject to change. EverPresent does not guarantee the absolute accuracy of competitor data. Please verify all information directly with the respective service provider.

Shipping & Drop-off Experience

All transport between our stores, your homes and our high-tech labs is handled by our private in-house logistics network that’s 100% devoted to safely transporting your precious photos and videos.

EverPresent

LegacyBox

iMemories

ScanCafe

CVS, Walmart

✅
Yes. Northeast, Delaware, Maryland, Virginia, DC, Florida

❌
Not available

❌
Not available

❌
Not available

❌
Not available

✅
Yes. Over 130 local stores.

❌
Not available

❌
Not available

❌
Not available

✅
Local stores receive
projects that are then shipped to Atlanta

✅
Included

✅
Included

❌
Surcharge

❌
Surcharge

✅
Included

✅
Free labels to be used on
any sized box

❌
Fully prepaid box; size limits

❌
Prepaid ship kit; size limits

✅
Prepaid ship kit or mail yourself

✅
Boxed and shipped for you at retail counter

Format Guides
8mm film

16mm film
Super8 film

Helpful Articles
Vinegar Syndrome: Symptoms, Causes and Prevention
How to preview old film before digitizing
How to use an 8mm film projector
Understanding film resolution and aspect ratios for digitizing
How to buy a projector to preview your films
How to spot dangerous nitrate film
How to tell the difference between audio and film reels
Safe care and handling guide for 8mm and 16mm film
How to tell if film reels have sound on them
How to quickly estimate how many feet of film you have

*Information regarding competitors is based on public research and market knowledge available at the time of publication. Product features, and service offerings are subject to change. EverPresent does not guarantee the absolute accuracy of competitor data. Please verify all information directly with the respective service provider.

Fill out this form or give us a call